Tiffin University (2-15-1, 2-11-1 G-MAC) could not hold a 1-0 lead, falling to Findlay in its season finale 2-1 in double overtime.
The tough loss came in the 110th minute, when Shannon Marsh gathered a loose ball around midfield and drilled it home to send the Oilers home with the victory.
After a scoreless first half, the Dragons had taken the lead initially, as Abby Morillon took a loose ball in front of the box and scored in the 48th minute.
Findlay did not answer until the 80th minute, when Sami Hild took a cross from Karleigh Clere to even the score at 1-1.
Findlay controlled much of the tempo, outshooting TU 24-5, including a big 11-4 mark in the second half. Findlay also had 14 corner kicks to Tiffin's 1.
Shelby Haworth took the loss in goal, making 7 saves over 110 minutes.